Friday, April 25, 2008

Comcast Expects Automatic Franchise Renewal

When Comcast of the Plainfields’ 10-year city franchise ends in 2009, the company will invoke a 5-year automatic renewal, a representative told the Cable Television Advisory Board Thursday.

Charles Smith III, director of Government and Community Affairs for Northern New Jersey, told the board, “Comcast will exercise that option. That’s the way we look at the franchise.”

Among topics the board discussed Thursday (April 24, 2008) was the process set forth by the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities, which calls for franchisees to begin a study of cable service delivery three years before the time of franchise renewal. The board is expected to deliver a report on the cable franchise this year, but the automatic renewal clause may make the process moot.

Still, the board may hold a public hearing on the community’s level of satisfaction with Comcast services.

While the Comcast franchise is running out, Verizon has gained state approval to hold franchises in many communities, including Plainfield. Smith said that when Verizon’s ability to serve customers reaches 60 percent of the Plainfield market, franchise fees will double from 2 percent to 4 percent due to state legislation. The city currently receives as much as $120,000 in franchise fees to operate the city’s local origination channel.

But while officials wrested the commitment for two local channels from Comcast in the past franchise renewal, the implementation has been spotty. Only one channel, based in City Hall Annex, is currently operating. A studio built at Maxson Middle School has languished.

Besides the operational aspects of the local channels, programming was another topic addressed by the board. Much of the local channel’s content is public service announcements and outside programs such as Democracy Now and White House Chronicles, but Public Information Officer Jazz Johnson said consultant Parris Z. Moore has launched a pilot program called “Hello Plainfield” and has several more in the works. They include “Plainfield at Work,” about day-to-day city activity on behalf of its citizens; “Plainfield Profiles,” about interesting residents; and “Plainfield Update,” a news format program.

See www.plainfield.com for the Channel 74 schedule. The board's next meetings will be 7 p.m. on May 22 and June 26 in City Hall Library.

Board members asked Johnson when the City Council meetings would be televised. Johnson said Channel 74 was ready to record the meetings, but the council was holding off.

Johnson said her goal is to have 70 percent local programming in the future.

“It is there. It is in the works,” she said.

--Bernice Paglia

Thursday, June 22, 2006

Comcast Offers Station Advice

Comcast officials said Monday (June 19, 2006) they are ready to help the city improve its local cable channel, but said the city must first decide what it wants.

Charles L. Smith III, area director for government and community affairs, and Peter J. Lyden III, senior director of franchise and government affairs for the New Jersey region, told City Council members the station can offer technical assistance and training once the city settles on whether it wants to show messages, live events, taped events or a combination. Comcast normally helps set up local channels and then, Lyden said, “We more or less back off - it’s the city’s channel.“

Smith said he was not aware of any ongoing issues with the local channel. Lyden said he would check with access coordinator Ed Robertson on whether the city has contacted Comcast about the quality of the local channel. He said the only way for Comcast to assess the quality would be to view Channel 74 inside the city.

“We do require the feedback from the viewers in the city,“ Lyden said.

As part of franchise negotiations in 1999, the city requested two local channels.

Comcast donated $150,000 for start-up costs and set aside 2 percent of its franchise fees, between $110,000 and $120,000, for operating costs. The city also received a $50,000 supplemental access grant this year.

Smith said no other municipality received more on a 10-year franchise.

At present, only Channel 74 is operating, largely on a message-board format. A school-based channel is not operating. Station Director Rebecca Williams was not retained by the new administration of Mayor Sharon Robinson-Briggs. A board that is supposed to oversee the operation currently has no members.

Lyden said probably the first thing the council should look at is whether to have a full-time or part-time person in charge of the station. He said some towns have volunteer station managers. Others rely on a city clerk. Lyden and Smith handed out packets describing how Woodbridge, Cranford and Union manage their local channels.

City Council President Ray Blanco began the discussion with a brief history of legislation related to the franchise. Blanco said in recent years, the Comcast funds meant for operation of the station went into the city’s general fund. He now wants to use some city surplus funds to restore the operations fund.

Blanco also asked Comcast to allow council members Linda Carter and Rayland Van Blake to visit stations in other towns. The two serve on a new advisory committee on cable operation.

Carter asked Smith what he felt was minimum staffing for a quality channel. Lyden said the station should at least have a full-time coordinator.

Smith said the 10-year franchise expires in August 2009 and suggested that the city soon begin a three-year “ascertainment” process on its cable service. Negotiations usually start in the last twelve months of the franchise, he said.

--Bernice Paglia

Friday, April 23, 2010

TV Board Plots Improvements

Members of the Plainfield Cable Television Advisory Board envision lots of positive changes for local channel programming, a meeting Thursday revealed.

Among the projected changes are a new logo, more up-to-date programs, increases in funding fees and a new approach to staffing.

The city formerly had one community access channel, Channel 74 on the Comcast of the Plainfields cable system. A conversion to digital broadcasting expanded offerings and put local programming on Channel 96. Verizon’s state franchise has provided Channel 34 now that FiOS penetration in the city has reached 60 percent. The same programs are now available both to Comcast and Verizon subcribers. The new logo will have the city’s colors, blue and gold, and will include both channels.

Viewers used to seeing re-runs of events that took place months ago will soon see more current programming, although consultant Parris Moore cautioned that there must be a flow of new content to avoid stale re-runs. Late in the meeting, PCTVAB Chairman Lamar Mackson introduced Les Wormack, whose documentary “Personal Stories: Walk to Live” may just be the harbinger of more interesting local content. Wormack gathered stories of people who walk or run at the Hub Stine track, including a cancer survivor and a nonagenarian.

“Our stories are magical,” Wormack said, calling them “stories of transformation.”

Wormack, a photographer for 30 years, said he will be submitting more of his video work to the cable station on the theme, “the journey, whatever our journey is.”

Charles L. Smith III, Comcast’s area director for community affairs, explained system changes and answered board members’ questions Thursday. Now that FiOS has reached the 60 percent capacity mark, he said, franchise fees will likely double in 2011. Comcast’s 2 percent franchise fee for 2009 was $92,197, paid in January.

Comcast has a 10-year franchise, with a five-year automatic renewal. The city is now in the renewal period and next year will begin a three-year “ascertainment” process toward a new franchise agreement. Verizon does not have to negotiate with the city, as it has a statewide franchise.

Board members expressed interest in having Comcast provide more programming, but Smith said, “I’ll respond by saying Comcast is not in the production business.”

At present, the city may seek use of a mobile truck with one Comcast staffer to record events such as parades, concerts and sports. Volunteers may receive training in use of equipment, but the single truck serves Union, Essex and parts of Middlesex County and its use must be booked far in advance of an event.

Meanwhile, the city’s only television station employee is facing a layoff by May 26. The city has had two rounds of layoffs due to budget constraints. But Chris Payne, the city’s new IT director, said the city is “aggressively working” on an alternate plan that may involve bidding for services. Payne said the city guarantees “no loss in service” to viewers.

Smith’s parting words to the board were an invitation to join in “Comcast Cares Day” from 8:30 a.m. to 1 p.m. Saturday, when employees and others will work on the city’s community garden on Berkeley Terrace.

--Bernice Paglia

Friday, April 04, 2008

Cable Increases, Franchise Renewal Up for Questions


Comcast of Plainfield began charging 19 percent more for its basic rate Jan. 1, even though the “proposed” new rate has not yet been approved by the state’s Board of Public Utilities.

Don’t fret, it’s legal, and if the BPU fails to approve the increase, cable customers will get the money back with interest.

Furthermore, according to a legal notice today, subscribers and other members of the public can weigh in on the increase by writing to a judge in the Office of Administrative Law. The deadline to comment is May 4 and the address is:
Honorable Richard McGill
Administrative Law Judge
Office of Administrative Law
33 Washington St., 7th Fl
Newark, NJ 07102

Comcast of Plainfield, which serves North and South Plainfield in addition to the Queen City, applied for the annual rate increase Oct. 1, 2007 as permitted by law. A bill from last year shows a total of $14.17 for the cable rate plus various fees. The bottom line now is $16.88. The cable fees alone were $13.80, increased to $15.80 per month.

The notice reminded Plaintalker of another issue, the cable franchise renewal process. According to a BPU report, more than 12,000 households had cable in 2005. The three-year process to determine how well Comcast has served Plainfield should have begun in August of 2006, with a report due in August of this year. The franchise expires in August 2009.

The Plainfield Cable Television Board was supposed to hold monthly meetings during the ascertainment period, make annual reports, report regularly to the mayor and council and generally to be involved in any activities having to do with local cable television, including the city’s own Channel 74.

Plaintalker has harped on this subject since December 2005 but there is not much progress to report. Click here for a file of past stories.

As an advisory board, the group probably is exempt from the Sunshine Law, but no reports have come forth. The board was established by ordinance four years ago and some members were appointed in 2006. In January, Council President Harold Gibson and City Council members Rashid Burney and Linda Carter were named liaisons to the committee.

Meanwhile, Verizon won the right to have franchises throughout New Jersey and according to the BPU, Verizon’s franchise here extends to December 2013. The clinker is that FIOS lines have not yet been installed everywhere, but lately FIOS trucks have been seen around the city. It would be interesting to know how the potential new competition will affect Comcast’s franchise renewal chances. At one point, a Comcast official alluded to an automatic five-year renewal when the 10-year franchise expires. But changing times may prevent a slam-dunk renewal.

There are lots of questions here that deserve a little explanation and updating. According to the council’s own Rules of Order, the Cable Television Advisory Board liaisons are supposed to report to the full council every four months. For 2008, could that be just about now?

--Bernice Paglia

Friday, July 10, 2009

Digital TV Coming Soon

From Peter Briggs:
Corrections to your story:

The Cable TV Advisory Board is not doing a presentation on Monday; that presentation is from the City Administrator.
Comcast has already applied for that 5 year extension.
Please don’t forget the 3 free boxes come with the stipulation about people who already have boxes do not get the 3 free. Only additional boxes that would total three and the price that they are currently paying for any boxes that they already possess would remain the same.


Digital conversions and other changes to Comcast of the Plainfields dominated the discussion Thursday at the Plainfield Cable Television Advisory Board meeting.

Charles L. Smith III, Area Director for Government and Community Affairs for Comcast, was on hand to answer questions that ranged from the impact of new technology to possible concessions to subscribers.

Smith outlined upcoming changes that will require subscribers to obtain converters to get digital reception, although some subscribers to basic analog reception may still keep what they normally receive. In that case, the company will have to rework digital transmissions back to analog for that class of subscribers. The new digital lineup will result in changes to channels, with Channel 74 expected to become Channel 6.

The change will come in two phases, one at the end of July and another at the end of August. The need for subscribers to get the converters is being explained in spots on Comcast as well as through mailings and ads. A subscriber can get up to three free converters and Smith said the Rock Avenue office is gearing up for an “onslaught.” Subscribers can also call to have the boxes delivered to their homes for self-installation.

Plainfield is the first system in Northern New Jersey to get the conversion, Smith said.

Ultimately, all transmission will be digital, Smith said, as the digital signal can be compressed to one-sixteenth of an analog signal.

Under the franchise agreement approved in 1999, Comcast was to have provided two local access channels, one for municipal government and one for educational purposes. Part of the discussion Thursday involved the possibility that there might be enough room on Channel 74 for content from both while further possibilities are explored. There is no extra channel in the analog lineup, so the second channel would mostlikely have to be digital.

Council liaisons Linda Carter and Annie McWilliams and Board of Education liaison Pat Barksdale successfully pushed in May for viewings of school board meetings, over city administration protests that Channel 74 was understaffed. Now the question is when best to schedule the school board meetings.

At the time of the franchise agreement, Comcast agreed to build two “returns” for local content, one at City Hall Annex and one at Maxson Middle School. Channel 74 operates out of the annex, although concerns continue over its programming. The middle school connection is not in use. Barksdale asked whether an educational channel return could be placed somewhere else, but Smith said the city would have to pay the cost.

Barksdale also asked whether Comcast would consider and “givebacks” or “rebates” to customers, but Smith said, “Rates are rates.”

The city’s 10-year franchise agreement with Comcast expires on Aug. 3, but Smith said the company will apply for an automatic five-year renewal. Although the Board of Public Utilities lists an ascertainment process that should have begun in 2006, Smith said the three-year process will start later. The process provides for public hearings on Comcast service and other concerns before a franchise renewal.

Members of the Cable Television Advisory Board are expected to make a presentation to the City Council Monday. The agenda-fixing session is at 7:30 p.m. in City Hall Library, 515 Watchung Ave.

--Bernice Paglia

Monday, March 26, 2007

Why No Cable Talks?

Freelancing as a reporter has definitely put a crimp in my blogging and everything else I like to do. Right now my lack of blog thoughts has caused the obnoxious Microsoft Office Assistant to take a snooze while awaiting my next keystrokes. That’s a first.

Part of my blog malaise also has to do with the paucity of council news. The last City Council meeting had 16 resolutions that were approved in a single vote and one ordinance that required a roll call vote. That part was all over in eight minutes.

More residents came out for the meeting than in past months and some had questions, mostly about the overpayment issue that was reported in the Plaintalker. But I know there are lots of other issues out there that could use a little attention by our elected representatives.

One such issue is the cable television franchise. As reported in Plaintalker last year, the city could have begun the ascertainment process in August. This preliminary process is meant to assess the current delivery of cable services to Plainfield customers, among other things. One person at Wednesday’s meeting asked about the 2 percent cable franchise revenue that is supposed to come back to the city for the operation of its local cable channel. There is also supposed to be a board that oversees the local cable channel, but it only has a few members.

City Administrator Marc Dashield assured the resident after the meeting that the local channel will soon improve. The larger question may be whether the city intends to pursue cable franchise renewal or will it adopt another technology. And if so, will there still be a local channel?

About 11,000 of Plainfield’s 15,000 households have Comcast cable. Verizon’s FIOS is not yet available in Plainfield, according to a check just now at their web site. But it probably will be by the time the Comcast franchise is up in August 2009. The company won a statewide franchise last year and is working on making service available to all municipalities.

So is anybody looking into this? Where’s the discussion? If all these proposed condos get built, there will be a lot more households affected by a franchise decision. Comcast representatives appeared at a City Council meeting last year to answer questions and to remind the council it was time to start the ascertainment process. Maybe Verizon representatives should be invited to explain what they can do for Plainfield.

A March 25 Courier News article reports on Somerville’s concern that its local channel is not yet available to residents who switched to Verizon. Read here.

If anyone has questions about the future of cable service and the local community channel, please let your elected officials know. Maybe it’s a good question for candidates who will file April 9 to represent you on local, county and state levels.

--Bernice Paglia

Wednesday, December 28, 2005

To-Do List: Appoint Television Board

Among the many decisions pushed off until after the New Year, the City Council recently declined to act on mayoral nominations for the Plainfield Cable Television Board.

The list was offered very late in the final year of Mayor Albert T. McWilliams’ tenure and contained at least one resume that dated back to 2003. Regardless of the past nominees and the dilatory nature of the submission, this board deserves early consideration by the new administration.

Some history: When Comcast‘s franchise was up for renewal in 1999, the city held numerous meetings to ensure the best terms. One of the city‘s demands was more local coverage and the final agreement allowed for two local origination channels.

So far, only one is up and running - Channel 74 - and even though it has a director, there is no board in place to set policy, oversee programming and report on usage of the local channel(s).

The ordinance that establishes the board also stipulates that all of the franchise fees owed to the city shall be dedicated to operation of the local channel. In the 2006 fiscal year, that amount is listed in the budget as $119,660.

Comcast spokesman Patrick MacElroy said Comcast pays 2 percent of the cable fees to the municipality and does not restrict its use. But in light of the city ordinance that dedicates its use, Councilman Ray Blanco recently questioned where the money has gone in the past four years.

Besides the issue of how best to use the franchise fees, another question is whether the city will exercise its right to hold hearings on the cable operation in 2006. MacElroy said the city has a 10-year franchise with an automatic five-year renewal, but the state Board of Public Utilities (BPU) says the city has the right to begin “ascertainment” hearings in August 2006, with comments from residents on cable performance and related issues, in advance of the 2009 interim renewal.

Despite MacElroy’s assertion that the renewal is only a matter of paperwork, the BPU schedule makes it clear that citizens can have their say on the cable operation if the city wishes to hold hearings.

Another issue is the matter of payment of a $50,000 grant that was due prior to a five-year review of the cable television operation. It is unclear whether any such review took place.

The bottom line is that the city wanted all the above concessions and may or may not have failed to follow through. It is up to the new administration to exert the rights the city fought so hard for.

The cable television board is supposed to have 11 members. The mayor, a city official and three council members, a Board of Education member, a Plainfield Public Library representative and four appointed citizens are to serve on the board. Three alternates may also be appointed.

According to BPU figures, 12,056, or 68 percent, of city households have cable television. That’s a lot of stakeholders in the city’s agreement with Comcast. There must be at least four citizens willing to serve on the cable television board.


--Bernice Paglia

KEYWORDS: cable, television

Thursday, March 19, 2009

Information Please

Monday's City Council meeting revealed that Channel 74 is basically on life support until more "resources," aka staff, can be hired.

According to City Administrator Marc Dashield, staffing levels "don't exist."

At the council's next meeting, a contract will be offered to re-hire a consultant who had been helping out with programming and production for Channel 74.

The issue arose during questioning of why the city can't offer viewings of school board meetings, even if all that is needed is to play a recording of a meeting. Councilwoman Linda Carter asked why a DVD of a meeting simply couldn't be played, but Dashield answered, "We don't have the resources to do it."

Public Information Officer Jazz Clayton-Hunt was recently let go from the staff, leaving only one employee in the department. Although that individual was taping the council meeting Monday, Dashield said the station was just being maintained with existing content and there was no capacity to run the TV station.

Council President Rashid Burney called for a detailed discussion at the next council meeting, which will take place April 6 at Emerson Community School.

The city receives more than $100,000 annually in franchise fees meant to fund operation of the local channel and Councilman Adrian Mapp said, "I am just at a loss to know why the station is not functioning."

Councilwoman Annie McWilliams asked for a schedule of what is currently being aired.

Meanwhile, a meeting of the Cable Television Advisory Board on March 12 did not have a quorum, Carter said. The board is supposed to oversee operations of the local origination channel and also to conduct hearings on cable matters.

Plaintalker has an archive on this issue as related to Comcast of the Plainfields. The advisory board had several duties it was supposed to undertake regarding franchise renewal. Franchise fees are supposed to double when Verizon's FiOS reaches a certain level of penetration in the city, but Plaintalker has not been able to get information on how far along FiOS is in the city.

However, as evidenced Monday, the franchise fees will not mean much if there is no staff or plan to implement programming.

As much as the incoming administration trashed Channel 74 operations in 2006, it appears not much progress has been made. Here is an opportunity where funding exists and all that is needed is execution, which remains lacking.

--Bernice Paglia

Friday, November 14, 2008

Commentary on TV Board Meeting

Wednesday's meeting of the Plainfield Cable Television Advisory Board was a depressing reminder of the need for better communications in the city.

Click here for Dan's report.

The board is supposed to oversee cable television activities, make recommendations and reports, serve as liaison with Comcast and "encourage and promote full utilization"' of cable television resources and more. The full ordinance, with all 16 duties and responsibilities, is posted on Councilman Rashid Burney's web site. Scroll down to Article 26.

Both the web site and the programming on Channel 74 remain weak, with little more than a year left to go in the current administration. On Wednesday, Public Information Officer Jazz Clayton-Hunt gave the board an overview of the programming on Channel 74, including coverage of seminars on business and home ownership, Plainfield Symphony performances, "Hello Plainfield" and "Plainfield @ Work" programs and community events.

But ongoing coverage of City Council meetings is still in the works. Board members said they often get requests for such coverage, but Clayton-Hunt cited technical issues. Staffing is another issue, board member Peter Briggs noted. The board asked Clayton-Hunt to prepare presentations on the programming and council coverage, possibly to be given at the Nov. 24 City Council agenda session.

The "Music in the Plaza" summer events were taped, but attendance was low, Clayton-Hunt said. In response to a board member who said she didn't know about the music events, Clayton-Hunt said they were publicized on the city's web site. True, but event listings are under "Community Resources," a link that sounds more like social service agencies.

Clayton-Hunt said her office also wants to invite "intellectual resources" in the city to take part in interviews, but there is no studio available. Board member Dottie Gutenkauf suggested checking the schools for space. Other possibilities discussed were the YWCA, the YMCA or Harvest Radio studios in Plainfield. School board member Rasheed Abdul-Haqq, who asked about the status of an educational channel provided for in the Comcast franchise, was asked to check on possible studio space in the schools.

Clayton-Hunt also presented a four-page "wish list" of equipment to improve communications, one page of which contained items needed immediately. Board member Jan Massey asked her for an inventory of current equipment, but she didn't have one. It is unclear how the wish list could be addressed now anyway, because the FY 2009 budget for the year ending June 30 is now being finalized

The board itself needs a chairman, more members and a meeting schedule for the coming year. Briggs, the husband of the mayor, was the chairman but had to step down due to board bylaws. The board does not have a list of current members, terms and vacancies. According to the Municipal Code, the board is supposed to have 11 members, but only three were present Wednesday.

Anyone wishing to serve on the board may download an application from the city web site and submit it to the mayor's office.

The next Cable Television Advisory Board meeting is 7 p.m. Dec. 16 in City Hall Library.

--Bernice Paglia

Sunday, July 27, 2008

Channeling Channel 74

After receiving the new schedule for Channel 74, I was able to catch the City Council meeting at 9 a.m. Tuesday. Here is Police Director/Public Safety Director Martin Hellwig explaining a police reorganization plan to the council. The audio suffered greatly from a noisy air conditioner in City Hall library and so not much could be heard. This was the June 10 agenda-fixing session.

On Wednesday, I told someone the council meeting was scheduled for 8 p.m., but it turned out another show was on.

I had hoped to see the June 30 school board meeting again, but on Saturday the screen froze into this interesting mosaic for a while and I went on to other things.
These are more or less trial runs for school and council meetings. Since June 30, there was a July 8 school board work-and-study session and a July 15 business meeting that I don't think were recorded. The City Council met on July 14 and 21, again with no recording that I know of.
Last week I ran into Parris Z. Moore, the consultant who is producing shows for Channel 74. He mentioned the time it takes to edit shows, but I said I thought the governmental shows were "gavel-to-gavel" and didn't have to be edited. It turns out he was talking about the hours needed to edit the new shows (Hello Plainfield and Plainfield at Work, for example) and there was only one person doing the editing.
Meanwhile, interest is building on getting the promised educational channel up and running. But there are many, many questions about how that could be accomplished. The Cable Television Advisory Board, which oversees Channel 74, has been meeting on fourth Thursdays, but two board members who tried to attend last Thursday found there was no meeting.
According to a Board of Public Utilities schedule, a report on the ascertainment process is due next month. This report is part of the franchise renewal schedule. The ascertainment phase begins three years before renewal and so should have begun in August 2006. It is supposed to include getting feedback from cable subscribers on how well Comcast is providing service. The franchise is up in 2009, although Comcast officials say they have the right to an automatic renewal.
A new issue - Verizon's FIOS availability - may soon also be on the table.
Considering that about 70 percent of city households have cable subscriptions, the local origination channel(s) could be a valuable communications tool. What would it take to make it happen? Any comments?
--Bernice Paglia

Thursday, March 02, 2006

Director Removed From Local Channel

The station master for Channel 74 said she was told to vacate the studio of the local channel Monday (Feb. 27, 2006).

Rebecca Williams said Personnel Director Karen Dabney came to the studio at 11:55 a.m. Monday with checks covering two weeks’ notice and terminal pay, then asked her to turn over the keys.

“I did that and left,” Williams said

Williams had been in charge of the local cable operations since June 2004, she said. No reason was given for her removal, she said, but she characterized it as “political retribution.” Williams had served as campaign manager for three City Council members who were associated with former Mayor Albert T. McWilliams when they sought political office.

Mayor Sharon Robinson-Briggs did not reply to a call to her office regarding future local cable operations. Under the tutelage of Assemblyman and Plainfield Democratic Party Chairman Jerry Green, Robinson-Briggs successfully overcame McWilliams’ bid last year for a third term. She took office Jan. 1.

Two weeks ago, she placed Police Chief Edward Santiago, a McWilliams appointee, on administrative leave until completion of a lawsuit he filed over a brief suspension in 2003. Also this week, McWilliams’ public information officer, Dan Damon, is leaving city employment.

Williams said Monday’s cable programming has been running all week, and she did not know whether there was anyone replacing her. She said she was qualified for the job because she had a background in film and television work and had taught graduate courses for four years at New York University’s Tisch School of Film and Arts. Williams said her removal showed “total disregard for the residents and the First Amendment.”

The city asked for its own channel when its franchise with Comcast of the Plainfields was up in 1999. Comcast agreed to furnish equipment and training. The city receives 2 percent of the franchise fees - about $120,000 last year - and dedicated the money for station operation. A Cable Television Board , with 11 members in seven categories, was to be established to oversee the operation. Recently, three City Council members were appointed, but the other seats are unfilled.

City Council President Ray Blanco said he would not comment on any personnel matters, but as a public and commercial television consultant, he did have some views on use of the local channel.

“As we all clearly know, there is not sufficient media coverage of the city,” he said. “This means of communication has a lot of potential to provide information to residents.”

Blanco said the channel could be a resource for emergency or Homeland Security information as well.

“ I would like to see the promise of the cable station fulfilled finally,” he said.

He noted the cable ordinance provided for two channels, one for the municipality and one for schools. He said he has talked to the school board and Superintendent Paula Howard about a joint venture with the city, with the goal of enhancing students’ academic skills through various aspects of television production.

“It would be a great tool to keep kids in school, and to keep kids engaged,” he said.

Blanco said he was “sort of” interested in having City Council meetings televised, but had questions about the cost .

For the future, he said, the city should “build a real plan with people in the profession,” decide whether to partner with the high school and explore the use of free music videos of various genres to expand programming.

--Bernice Paglia

KEYWORDS: Channel 74, cable station

Sunday, November 02, 2008

Random Thoughts on City Issues

By chance, Plaintalker turned on Channel 74 Saturday and saw a program on the Mayor's Summer Youth Program. There were many aspects to this presentation that deserve comment, but rather than give my immediate thoughts, I would prefer to hear from readers. The program will be broadcast Sundays at 9 a.m. and 7:30 p.m., Mondays at 9:30 a.m. and 10 p.m., Thursday at 10 a.m., Friday at 2 p.m. and Saturday at 1:30 p.m., if I read the schedule correctly.

The program features Finance Director Douglas Peck instructing a group of teens on how to do PowerPoint presentations. The young people had studied certain city divisions and were going to report on their assessments. The group then discussed the findings and the program concluded with a formal presentation to the mayor.

Check it out.

Among her responses, the mayor mentioned the possibility of a youth center. This notion has come up in several public gatherings, with the idea of purchasing the Armory or another building for such a purpose. Two thoughts come to mind. First, how can the city afford to buy a building for a youth center when it came out in budget talks that the South Avenue firehouse needs to be replaced at a projected cost of $7 million? And secondly, is this proposal reflected anywhere in the capital budget or is it just a campaign promise for 2009?

As you will see, the young people noticed a distinct lack of technological expertise in several areas of city operations, as well as issues with the web site. At a recent meeting, a council member suggested that the city should take a cue from the school district's web site. However, the district web site has changed shape lately. Frequent viewers see things come and go as if the site is still in test mode. For example, the link to PPS News was missing yesterday and a new item, "The Insider," disappeared after one issue. Given the controversy over whether Parents Empowering Parents is an "outside" organization, the title seemed a bit off the mark.

Looking at Channel 74 in a rare sitdown before the TV Saturday also made this writer wonder what's up with the city's Cable Television Advisory Board. Click here for two previous posts on talks with Comcast officials. Verizon has a statewide franchise and is building out its FiOS service in the city. When the service level reaches 60 percent, franchise fees are supposed to double to 4 percent. But how will the city know when that benchmark kicks in? The board is supposed to monitor operations of the local channel, which still has limited local coverage.

City officials floated the idea of hiring a director of technology at a projected salary of around $147,000 at one budget session. The Police Division has also revised its table of organization to include two new bureaus, one for technology. Someone suggested that talented individuals in-house could handle city technology needs. Will the FY 2009 final budget resolve the issue or will there be more tinkering with one of the city's biggest problems?

The City Council is on election hiatus and the school district is closed next week, so none of these local questions will get answered for a while. Meanwhile, everyone who is registered to vote should have received a sample ballot. Check your polling place, read the two public questions, review voting machine instructions and above all, don't forget to vote on Tuesday!

--Bernice Paglia

Thursday, May 14, 2009

TV Board Revitalization Sought

City Council reorganization and mayoral address on Channel 74.

Members of the Plainfield Cable Television Advisory Board and other officials are seeking to fill board seats as questions continue regarding the functioning of Channel 74.

Lacking a quorum Thursday, members held an informal discussion on how to revitalize the board, which has oversight of the local origination channel provided by Comcast of the Plainfields. Programming has been stalled since early spring, since the loss of the city public information officer and the need to contract with a consultant who formerly developed shows for the channel.

At its May 11 meeting, the City Council approved a contract with Blok Box LLC, which had previously served in the 2007-08 fiscal year and had qualified to 2008-09, but until this month had no contract.

The advisory board needs more citizen members as a first step and at Thursday's meeting detailed several other steps necessary to get programming to the level desired by the public. One key issue lately is to have school board meetings aired, as City Council meetings have been in recent months. School board member and liaison to the City Council Patricia Barksdale presented a DVD to City Council member Linda Carter Monday, saying it was one of five or six awaiting airing on Channel 74.

The TV board has several categories of membership, including a mayoral designee, a city official, three council members, representatives of the school board and public library, four citizens and three citizen alternates. The mayor's designee is her husband, Peter R. Briggs. Carter and Councilman Rashid Burney are two of the council representatives, the third being unclear. Jan Massey and Quadir Lewis are citizen members.

Councilwoman Annie McWilliams attended Thursday's TV board meeting and pledged to recruit more citizen members, while Barksdale said she will look into assignment of a school board liaison. TV board members will check with City Clerk Laddie Wyatt on the status of other seats.

The TV board's chairperson must come from the Class VI citizen category and at present there is no chairman or secretary.

Any citizen interested in serving on the Plainfield Cable Television Advisory Board may download an application form from the city web site, fill it out and return copies to Wyatt and to the mayor's office. Terms are for three years or the unexpired portion of such a term.

The duties and responsibilities of the TV advisory board include making recommendations to mayor and council on cable operations, making annual reports to the same and to "encourage and coordinate the use of all available technical equipment and expertise needed by the public and private organizations and private individuals to produce cable television programs," among many others listed in Article 26 of the Agencies and Boards section of the Municipal Code.

The board has dealt with Comcast of the Plainfields since its inception, but is also exploring possibilities of expanded franchise fees and service as Verizon FiOS takes hold in Plainfield.

--Bernice Paglia

Saturday, January 02, 2010

2010 State of City Report Online

Mayor Sharon Robinson-Briggs launched her second term by putting her State of the City report online and promised better communication witht he public in 2010.

The mayor handed out hard copies of the 30-page report at the annual reorganization meeting and presented key points with a display of charts and graphics.

Communication was an issue in her first term, as residents complained that both the city's web site and the local cable channel were below par. Last year, the City Council approved the establishment of an IT manager post that will include oversight of public information dissemination.

The administration revived the post of public information officer during the mayor's first term, but the last person holding the job left city employment in March 2009. Around that time, the cable channel programming stalled for lack of staff. The cable operation still has only one employee and one consultant, but the Cable Television Advisory Board was recently invigorated with new members and Lamar Mackson as chairman. Once the IT manager is hired, it is expected that the advisory board will help gear up the operation. At present, there is one municipal channel, although a franchise agreement with Comcast of the Plainfields allows for an educational channel as well.

The city receives about $100,000 in franchise fees for the local cable operation, which will double when Verizon's FiOS reaches a certain level of penetration in the city.

For the immediate future, the mayor's main concern will be securing cabinet members to serve in her four-year term. Her nominations of Corporation Counsel Dan Williamson and Police Director/Public Safety Director Martin Hellwig for second terms both won City Council approval and were sworn in Friday. The council also approved her nomination of David Brown II as director of Public Works & Urban Development, but Brown was absent Friday.

The mayor named Bibi Taylor acting city administrator and acting director of Administration, Finance, Health & Social Services Friday and Taylor was sworn in, but will be leaving for a position in East Orange in 30 days. Taylor served as AFH&SS director since July 2009. Former City Administrator Marc Dashield resigned to become Montclair's township manager and former PW&UD Director Jennifer Wenson Maier was not reappointed.

--Bernice Paglia

Monday, July 06, 2009

TV Board meets Thursday

The Cable Television Advisory Board will meet Thursday to continue addressing its myriad issues of membership, operations at Channel 74, programming content and community involvement, among others.

At the June meeting, members discussed airing of school board meetings, public use of video equipment, the board’s function and staffing issues. Although the city negotiated establishment of two local channels in a franchise agreement 10 years ago, only one – the municipal channel - is operating. While still waiting for the school district to have its own channel, city and school board liaisons to the TV board have successfully pushed for DVDs of monthly Board of Education meetings to be added to the schedule along with City Council meetings. Still at issue is the best time for maximum viewership by parents.

The TV board is charged with supervising operations of Channel 74, but station staffing has been spotty. For most of the year so far, only one person has been on staff. A retroactive contract to July 1, 2008 for a production consultant was only passed in May and ran out June 30. So far, no new contract has been presented for council approval. The lack of staff has also hindered possible public access to production equipment, but the TV board also needs to formulate policies and procedures for such use. Members said they would look into how other municipalities handle citizen involvement.

Plainfield Public Library Director Joseph Hugh Da Rold came up at last month’s meeting with several suggestions, including a future film festival for independent productions, loaning of Board of Education meeting DVDs in addition to airing on Channel 74 and combining an outreach for new members with an announcement about an impending change in the channel lineup of Comcast of the Plainfields.

Later this month, Channel 74 will become Channel 6 as Comcast goes digital and revises its lineup.

The TV board has several categories of members, but currently lacks a chairman because the title must be held by a resident appointee. Any resident interested in serving can apply by filling out a form downloadable from the city’s web site. Meanwhile, the public is welcome to attend the meeting at 7 p.m. Thursday in City Hall Library, 515 Watchung Ave.

--Bernice Paglia

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

New Life for Cable Board

The Plainfield Cable Television Advisory Board has a new chairman, three prospective new members, a web site and a mission to improve programming.

Chairman Lamar David Mackson made a presentation to the City Council Monday on goals and recent achievements of the board, which had been languishing in recent years for lack of members. Former chairman Peter Briggs had to step down last summer after a review of rules revealed he was ineligible to serve because he is the mayor's designee and the chairman must be a Class IV citizen member. Among his remarks, Mackson noted three other citizens - Kieran N. Anderson, Lesli Price Hall and Michael C. Allen - are seeking mayoral nomination and council approval to serve. Other members include Plainfield Public Library Director Joe Da Rold, Councilwomen Annie McWilliams and Linda Carter and Board of Education member Patricia Barksdale.

McWilliams and Carter have consistently pushed for revitalization of the board, which is responsible for oversight of local Channel 96 (formerly Channel 74) and interaction with cable providers. In a franchise agreement with Comcast of the Plainfields, the city received two local channels, one for municipal programming and one for education, but the latter has yet to be set up.

On Monday, Mackson named three goals:

- To encourage community participation by providing a public forum for dialogue.
- To provide training and internship programs in an effort to engage our residents.
- To provide quality programming and services to our residents and neighbors.

Among achievements, Mackson named his appointment and identification of the three proposed new members, drafting of policies and procedures, a preliminary agreement between the advisory board and the Plainfield Board of Education for an internship program, establishment of contact with Verizon and a schedule for rollout of PEG (Public Educational Government) access. In addition, a web site is now up at http://pctvab.wordpress.com/

Mackson asked the governing body for reviews of current and past operating budgets for PCTV 96, an inquiry into operating procedures, setup of a franchise fee share agreement, some possible funding support from the city, confirmation of the three new members and more synergy between the advisory board and the city's Media/Station Operations unit.

Residents and council members have voiced many complaints about the local channel and the administration's communications in general, especially the quality of the official city web site. A public information official who managed the media unit left in March and the administration hopes to place the unit under a new technology manager. The title was recently approved by the City Council, but no one has yet been named to the post.

Mackson also offered a timeline for improvements. It is posted on the board's web site (link above).

The board's next meeting is at 7 p.m. Nov. 19 in the conference room at City Hall, 515 Watchung Ave.

--Bernice Paglia

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Non-Meetings and Community Forums

Like Dr. Yood, I inquired Monday about the City Council meeting agenda, only to be told there was no agenda and no meeting. No reason was cited.

My e-mail to Council President Harold Gibson asking the reason was not answered, but Gibson told Courier News reporter Mark Spivey "scheduling conflicts" were involved and that the meeting was not originally scheduled.

Lack of a quorum should have been known by Friday, barring any last-minute emergencies. And by Friday the agenda should have been ready to send out to council members. Furthermore, the Aug. 25 agenda session was on the council's published schedule. Because regular meetings are normally on the first and third Mondays of each month, agenda sessions are on the preceding Mondays. On Aug. 25, the council members would have decided on agenda items to be voted on at the Sept. 2 meeting. Because Sept. 1 is Labor Day, the meeting falls on a Tuesday. But now that meeting will also be skipped.

Something just doesn't sound right here. My calls to other council members were not answered. It is not like the council members, armed with their analog and electronic calendars, to be so dim about meeting dates. There should be a simple answer as to why the business of the city in September will now be compressed to one agenda session and one regular meeting as it was in June, July and August for the so-called summer hiatus.

Tonight is the mayor's forum, from 6:30 to 8 p.m. at Washington Community School. The school's official address is on Darrow Avenue, but access to the cafetorium is best made from the Spooner Avenue parking lot. Originally billed as featuring presentations on public safety and fiscal governance, the forum may turn out to be another session on issues related to the closing of Muhlenberg Regional Medical Center. The Save Muhlenberg group that meets every Monday is now the Restore Muhlenberg group and will attend the forum, activist Dottie Gutenkauf said Monday. If so, the Courier News will undoubtedly provide ongoing coverage.

On Thursday, Schools Superintendent Steve Gallon III will lead a Town Hall meeting on the school district, from 7 to 9 p.m., also at Washington Community School. As Maria Pellum has pointed out, since July 1 the district is in full gear, communicating with staff, parents, and all other stakeholders in the school system. There are three other Town Hall meetings set at locations across the city, so some may wait until one is held in their own neighborhoods.

The newly-improved district web site includes a count-down clock to the opening of school, which one hopes will be much happier than the close of school in June. The Park & Seventh neighborhood at that time saw a full police response to dismissal from the high school over several days, with crowds of students running through parking lots and fights breaking out. Most older people around here try not to be out at dismissal time anyway, mindful of their frailty when large groups of youth are dominating the sidewalks, but the end-of-school disruptions were truly appalling.

The community will be watching as the 2008-09 school year opens, when students return to a district full of new promise among its adult stakeholders. The 6,600 students, especially the 1,800 at the high school, will be called on to do their part as learners and "the best human beings they can be," as the new saying goes. They, too, will be expected to deliver "tangible and measurable" results.

Note: I am advised by Chairman Peter Briggs that the Aug. 28 meeting was rescheduled to Aug. 21 and the next meeting may be in October. The first Town Hall date coincides with the August meeting date of the Plainfield Cable Television Advisory Board, which is scheduled to give a report this month on the three-year ascertainment portion of the franchise renewal process. Verizon has begun soliciting customers for its FIOS service, in competition with the current franchise holder, Comcast of the Plainfields. The board did not meet last month and people with questions about the local access channels may be looking for answers Thursday.

It's shaping up as kind of a spotty week for meeting mavens. But then there will be the three-day weekend to rest up and relax before school opens and the politicking for November and June begins in earnest.

--Bernice Paglia

Friday, June 19, 2009

TV Issues Abound

Random image: Yellow hollyhocks.

I attended Thursday's Cable Television Advisory Board meeting but couldn't post due to the misbehaving computer. Today the modem didn't work all morning, giving me time to think about the issues raised. They include the need to recruit more residents to serve on the board, scheduling, policies to put in place on use of equipment, Comcast changes and many more. Looking at old blog posts when the internet link came back, I saw that in 2006 Comcast officials advised the board to begin the three-year ascertainment process toward franchise renewal, but later the officials said there was an automatic five-year renewal. I wondered how that deal came about in 1999 and whether, with all the changes in administration, the city still has a copy of the contract on file. I would love to see the exact language of the terms.

Anyway, the subject became larger in my mind that a quick summary of a meeting. I will try to work on it in Word so I can pop it in when the internet window opens for a while.

P.S. The darn thing went off three times while I tried to finish this, so I am stopping right here.

--Bernice

Wednesday, March 03, 2010

Council Liaisons Give Reports

City Council members gave numerous reports Monday on special committees and liaison assignments for 2010.

The committee and liaison structure was initiated by the late Councilman Ray Blanco in 2006 when he was council president. After his untimely death that year, the system faded away, but was brought back last year. The plan called for committees and liaisons to report to the full council at regular intervals, but reports were spotty in 2009. Councilwoman Annie McWilliams became council president in January and is asking for written reports as well as oral reports at meetings in 2010.

Among reports Monday:

-Councilwoman Bridget Rivers, liaison to the Plainfield Municipal Utilities Authority and the Housing Authority of Plainfield, said the PMUA is reaching out to other municipalities (to provide services and bring in outside revenues). Among concerns is a situation where the PMUA must pick up trash whether city property owners pay or not. (Recently a major landlord was found to be several thousand dollars in arrears.)

Rivers said the Housing Authority is working with Police Director Martin Hellwig to develop a strategy to reduce crime at its West End properties, but needs more community support.

- Councilman William Reid, a former PMUA commissioner now serving as liaison to the PMUA, reported that at its annual reorganization the PMUA board of commissioners elected Harold Mitchell chairman, The Rev. Tracey Brown vice-chair, Carol Brokaw secretary and Alex Toliver treasurer. The board also adopted a resolution to suspend travel for one year.

- Councilwoman Linda Carter, also liaison to the Housing Authority, said the agency received $1.3 million in federal Stimulus funding to improve housing units. The agency is also seeking $9 to $13 million to revitalize Elmwood Gardens.

- Council President McWilliams, liaison to the Special Improvement District, said the SID was supporting several events such as Music in the Plaza and a car show. Another initiative is identifying priorities for the district, such as safety, cleanliness or signage.

McWilliams is also liaison to the Plainfield Cable Television Advisory Board and reported that Corporation Counsel Dan Williamson is reviewing the board’s policies and procedures. Local Channel 96 is airing the January Board of Education meeting and reviewing requests from citizens for airing other material. The board is planning to have an unpaid internship for the channel.

(My notes are not clear on McWilliams’ remarks about Verizon setting up a second public access channel - more later.)

Mc Williams recommended careful review of any consultants, noting questions arose over what the most recent consultant was providing and why some meetings have not been aired.

There were further reports from council committees Monday, but Plaintalker will post separately on those items.

The liaison reports were informative to the extent that the public knew some background and context to the items discussed. For example, the Verizon issue is a story in itself. Comcast of the Plainfields set up Channel 74, now Channel 96, as part of its franchise agreement with the city many years ago. Verizon sought franchise approval across the state from the Board of Public Utilities more recently, but had to reach a certain degree of FiOS fiber optic installation before having to share revenues with municipalities and to provide local access channels (to this writer’s best recollection).

The reports took up an hour or so of the meeting before the council got around to legislative matters. Dr. Harold Yood gets the Blogger Endurance Award for staying to the end of the meeting, which ran past 11:30 p.m. This blogger bailed at 10 p.m. and another one left even earlier, at 8:45 p.m.

--Bernice Paglia

Monday, May 04, 2009

Contract May Cure Channel 74 Woes

A proposed resolution Monday to hire a media consultant for Channel 74 promised improvement, but also raised many questions about money, the station's mission and its execution.

The local origination channel was a hard-won trophy of the city's franchise negotiations about 10 years ago. In fact, there was to be both a municipal and a school district channel. Recently, officials have escalated the demand for a school district channel.

Meanwhile, the resolution spoke to the need for programming on the city channel. It seems a past consultant in the 2007-08 budget year, Blok Box, was not qualified for the contract until Aug. 18, 2008 in the FY 2009 budget year. The consultant worked until February, racking up a tab of $23,400, which was paid. But there was other work for which the consultant was not paid.

Not being a math whiz, Plaintalker was thinking that the consultant would get the $23,400 plus the $50,000 and also an undisclosed amount owed. Officials clarified Monday that the total amount could not exceed $50,000.

Nonetheless, this consultant did not apparently start work until 49 days into the fiscal year and then was off from February to the present.

One wonders, why and how were funds expended without a contract for most of the year and how come now the city is playing legal catch-up?

City Administrator Marc Dashield said the city will have the TV consultant qualification and the contract coincide for the 2010 fiscal year.

The city established a Cable Television Advisory Board several years ago to oversee the local channel, but it has lacked full membership and has not addressed issues such as the pending franchise renewal process with Comcast of the Plainfields.

Plaintalker has not viewed Channel 74 much lately, but would be interested in comments or observations on its function in recent times.

--Bernice Paglia